Reviews

Keyboards Plus review by Susan Nares,
YES (Yamaha Education Supplement) Number 26, 1997

Many more schools are using keyboards as the basic instrument for classroom music teaching. However the hardware developments have often not been matched by the supporting software. For many teachers the start of group keyboard lessons involves a fruitless search for suitable teaching materials and then a scramble to write their own. Some of this work has been developed sufficiently to be published. Susan Nares reviews one in a number of books received at the CODA Music Centre:

My interest was kindled when I heard that the new Keyboard Plus tutor was being aimed at class teaching as well as for individual tuition. In the words of the author, Derek Hobbs, the aim of the first volume is, 'to provide sufficient material to give beginners a thorough grounding in the basic skills of the keyboard.' The pieces are original and well thought out, providing some entertaining material...

Lots of Material
The layout of the book is clear and...uses a minimum of words in preference for plenty of material. This leaves the teacher free to expand, where necessary, on any information given. This book does not attempt to be a 'self-tutor', a point which is definitely in its favour!Derek Hobbs uses some very innovative approaches in this tutor. He introduces some of the pieces in bits and assembles them step by step, a process he names 'Tune-Builders'. This encourages the students towards the development of good practice technique, an invaluable lesson.

The inclusion of rhythmic drills is very helpful giving plenty of practice in all three areas of reading, recognition and performance of rhythms. In these 'rhythmic drill' sections there a plenty of suggestions for extension activities such as getting one player to perform a rhythm and then asking the others in the group to identify which one it was.The saying of rhythms using the French time names is encouraged as well as clapping. There is also an opportunity given to attempt some simple improvisations choosing your own group of notes and using one of the given rhythms to turn it into a tune.

G hand position
One very noticeable difference in Derek Hobbs's tutor is that he uses the G hand position in preference to the more usual 'middle C' approach. I personally welcome this as a much more comfortable position for the usual six octave electronic keyboard than holding fast to the more traditional piano tutor approach. However, some teachers may find this limiting if they are using any accompanying material which favours the 'C' method.

Single Fingered Chords
The Keyboard Plus tutor encourages students to play using single-fingered chords throughout this first volume. This is one of the things which makes this book so usable, especially for groups of mixed ability. Right from the start the pieces use a rhythm or one chord accompaniment which should result in everyone getting satisfaction from their music making whilst learning to make use of all the fun elements that keyboards offer.When the student progresses on to using more than one chord in a piece, Derek Hobbs turns this into a manageable task by presenting the new piece and its chords in a staggered way. 'Spaced-out tunes', as he calls them, may take some of the pain out of playing hands together particularly with such titles as 'Spaced-out Blues'!Ensemble Playing
Of particular interest to those of you teaching in groups will be the inclusion of plenty of opportunities for ensemble playing (more is promised in volume two.) Also included is an easy to use 'Progress Checklist' for pupils' self-assessment which could be adapted for use by the teacher for assessment and differentiation.

All in all I feel this book offers a very welcome alternative choice to those tutors currently available, particularly for key stages 3 and 4+. It encourages good practice through lively material. The emphasis seems to be in developing note reading and technical skills, possibly at the expense of aural development. This is, however, offset by the inclusion of ideas for improvisation...I look forward to seeing volume two, due out this summer. Christmas Keyboard Plus is also available.

.

Greatest Show on EarthTypical reviews St Columba's Players
'THE GREATEST SHOW ON EARTH'
Director Graham Nicol
Musical Director Judith Crawford

This was described in the publicity as being a Nativity story with a difference. The difference is that the story is told against a circus setting, complete with ringmaster, clowns, acrobats, knifethrower etc., obviously influenced by 'Godspell' and 'Joseph', but none the worse for that.

Since we all know the plot, the main interest lay in how well the treatment worked, and this was very successful, told with a certain reverence, apart from some possibly dubious taste involving the aforementioned knife-throwing by Herod's henchman and male babies. Humour was much to the fore, and the music was very tuneful, and, at times, moving. Performances from the whole company of forty or so were very confident, and conveyed the enjoyment of those Involved, from children to grandparents. Billy Meeks, as Joseph, in particular, impressed with his portrayal of a simple, but warm and understanding artisan. One of the highlights of the second act was the very funny rendering by one of the Roman Guards of the plaintive 'I'm Not Drunk'.

Director Graham Nicol had expertly tailored his production to the awkwardness of the stage erected in the nave of the church, and had managed to include some beautiful special effects. Honours too to the lighting and sound engineers. Perhaps 'miracles' is not an appropriate word, given the venue, but they certainly worked wonders under very difficult conditions. Judith Crawford led the excellent small band and directed the music from the piano.

The cast battled (successfully, for the most part) with the acoustics of the cavernous space, and some of the ensemble singing was splendid. All in all, a most enjoyable performance of a work which I would not hesitate to recommend other groups as a Christmas production.

NODA News


The Greatest Show on Earth
De Lisle Upper School, Loughborough

Autumn term closed on a lively note at the De Lisle School in Loughborough with a high-spirited production from the Upper School of the seasonal musical The Greatest Show on Earth.The Kirkup/Hobbs show is in the Rock Gospel vein, setting the christmas story within a circus framework. There is much allegory, and theproduction was given an inventive "youth theatre" treatment which created a colourful, spontaneous feeling, admirably maintained throughout.

Producer Tricia Coxon emphasised the sction packed circus theme, taking her young folk into the audience with ballons, streamers and general good cheer, sparking up the evening with a bright atmosphere.Musical director Andrew Lawson had coaxed a smashing response from his singing chorus (bags of well defined harmonies) who filled in the stage spaces with attractive background pictures. Solos and chorus numbers were backed by a well balanced band of confident musicians who delivered a tight punchy sound, underpinning mood and atmosphere.

Musical numbers were sharply contrasted; quiet love songs worked well alongside big, brash, band-the-drum outpourings and the rousing march SPQR which opened act II.The young cast tackled the tricky dual roles with vocal clarity and sensitive teamwork. The parts were written as two sides of what may not be quite the same coin, bending and blending historical fact, Christian tradition and circus caricatures into one character. For instance, Herod is also the physically powerful lion-tamer with all the sub-plottings, overtones and role-playing associated with both or either...

Coalville Times, Leics.

Review of Bewick's Footsteps Northern Review, Issue 10, April 1996

Newbiggin musician Derek Hobbs, whose most recent success was the community oratorio 'Fell 'em Doon' at the Newcastle Proms last autumn, has turned to the engravings of Thomas Bewick for his latest creation.His beautifully produced book features 24 tunes, each paired with a printed engraving. The tunes are varied in manner and pitched so as to suit a variety of instruments, including Northumbrian Pipes, fiddle and penny whistle.It is sometimes difficult to feel the connection between the tune and the picture, but some are very clear.

Toy boats on the Tyne, for example, is a haunting slow air capturing perfectly the lzy feel of a summer afternoon as the lads in Bewick's picture try out their boats on the river, as the young artist did himself as a boy.Hens around the Yard has an amusing way of imitating the pecking action of poultry and the jerking of the head, but Bewick's print is of a farmyard with an amazing variety of birds, as it should be since it was made for his History of British Birds.The Cuckoo's Tune features that bird's characteristic falling third and the tune of The Weelright circles around in a satisfying way......

Another slow air, High Tide does include some delicious major seventh chords against its haunting Aolean mode melody. Walking the Hog is an amusing evocation of Bewick's man being dragged along by the string tied to his pig's back leg.There is another lovely slow air to illustrate the peaceful scene at Bewick's birthplace, Cherryburn, Eltringham, alas no longer so peaceful as it was even 25 years ago when I lived thereabouts.Derek Hobbs has produced a charming and varied collection which should draw a big audience in this region and further afield.

KEVIN STEPHENS

Fell 'em Doon Review, (Brass Review)

Fell 'em DoonMusic: Derek Hobbs
Libretto: Mike Kirkup
Hire available: Rossleigh Music

Cantatas for mixed voices and brass band are, to say the least, thin on the ground, so the publication of "Felt 'Em Doon" is a most welcome addition to both the choral and banding repertoire and could be used to great advantage when the two share the same platform.The work was commissioned by 20,000 Voices and the Ashington Festival, with funds made available from Northern Arts. The first performance, as part of A Century of Coal, was given at the Ashington Festival, in October, 1994.Scored for baritone, soprano and mixed choirs, the bands accompanying the voices at the Ashington Festival were Ellington Colliery Band, Gregg's Bakery Band and Wansbeck Ashington Colliery Band.

"Fell 'Em Doon" was the nickname Of the first pit sunk at Ashington in 1849 and Derek Hobbs' score with Mike Kirkup's libretto reflect the many aspects of life around the pit.The accompaniment though technicatly unlikely to pose any problems for bands taking this cantata "on board" will, however, need to spend some time with balance for the solo voices.

There are some lovely moments, "Long Row, Cross Row", "Paint Us A Picture" and the final "Colliers' Requiem" to name but three.This work has many performance possibilities. A first-class musical school could tackle it, so could a band and local choral society. Band concerts are often in great need of offering something new to customers. Why not try this fifty minute work as a change? The band parts are available on hire, further details from Rossieigh Music, Rossleigh House, Windsor Terrace, Newbiggin-by-the-Sea, Northumberland, NE64 6UJ.Dennis Wilby

Newcastle Journal